What Are the Best Neighborhoods in Indiana for Rental Properties?

Some of the most desirable neighborhoods for rental properties in Indiana include Carmel, Fishers, Bloomington, West Lafayette, and Fort Wayne. These areas have strong job markets, good school districts, and growing populations of renters. Proximity to major universities like Indiana University and Purdue also drives rental demand.

What Are the Average Rental Prices in the Best Neighborhoods for Rental Properties in Indiana?

Rental prices in top Indiana neighborhoods range from around $1,000/month for a 1-bedroom apartment to over $2,000/month for a 3-4 bedroom single family home. For example, in Carmel the average rent is about $1,500 for a 2-bedroom and $2,100 for a 3-bedroom. In Bloomington, rents average $1,100 for a 1-bedroom and $1,700 for a 3-bedroom.

Learn More: loans on rental property

Which Neighborhoods in Indiana Have the Highest Rental Prices?

Some of the most expensive rental markets in Indiana include downtown Indianapolis, Carmel, Fishers, and central neighborhoods in Bloomington. High demand from professionals and proximity to major employers drives up prices in these areas. Rents for newer luxury apartments in downtown Indy can top $2,000/month for a 1-bedroom.

What Factors Contribute to the High Rental Prices in Some Indiana Neighborhoods?

Low vacancy rates, high demand from students and professionals, proximity to major employers, new construction, and desirable amenities drive rental prices upward in many Indiana neighborhoods. Areas with new luxury apartments can also command premium rents. Population and job growth in cities like Indianapolis, Fishers, and Carmel also push prices higher.

How Have Rental Prices in Indiana Changed Over the Past Decade?

Indiana rents have increased significantly over the past decade, outpacing national averages in many markets. For example, rents in Indianapolis have increased 50% since 2011. Strong demand has led to low vacancy rates and accelerated rent growth across the state. However, growth has cooled slightly in recent years as new construction has caught up with demand.

What Is the Highest and Lowest Rental Price for a Single-Family Home in Indiana?

Rental prices for single-family homes have a wide range across Indiana. In more affordable markets like Fort Wayne or Evansville, single-family home rents may range from $1,000 to $1,500 per month. In pricier areas like Carmel and Fishers, rental prices for 3-4 bedroom homes can easily top $2,500 per month. The lowest rents tend to be found in smaller rural markets.


Rental demand remains strong across much of Indiana, driven by job and population growth. Investors should focus on markets with major employers, universities, and high quality of life to maximize returns. While rents have risen rapidly, more new construction may slow future growth in some areas. However, Indiana remains an attractive market for rental real estate overall.

Back To Top